image of silk fabric and dry skin

J. K. L. Tan, MD, FRCPC

Department of Medicine, University of Western Ontario and Acne Research and Treatment Center, Windsor, ON, Canada

ABSTRACT

This paper reviews current evidence presented by recent studies on the impact of acne on psychosocial health. Study methodologies, including case-control and cross-sectional surveys, have demonstrated psychological abnormalities including depression, suicidal ideation, anxiety, psychosomatic symptoms, including pain and discomfort, embarrassment and social inhibition. Effective treatment of acne was accompanied by improvement in self-esteem, affect, obsessive-compulsiveness, shame, embarrassment, body image, social assertiveness and self-confidence. Acne is associated with a greater psychological burden than a variety of other disparate chronic disorders. Future studies with a longitudinal cohort design may provide further validation of the causal inference between acne and psychosocial disability provided by the current literature.
Key Words: acne, psychological well-being, Quality of Life

The interaction of acne and psychosocial issues is complex and, in adolescence, can be associated with developmental issues of body image, socialization and sexuality. Previous studies on the psychosocial impact of acne have documented dissatisfaction with appearance, embarrassment, self-consciousness, and lack of self-confidence in acne patients. Social dysfunction has also been observed, including concerns about social interactions with the opposite gender, appearances in public, interaction with strangers, and reduced employment opportunities.

The development of psychometric scales to measure the impact of disease on abstract concepts and the notion of Quality of Life (QoL) has facilitated greater understanding of the impact of acne on psychological well-being and socialization. This paper reviews the current evidence presented by some of these studies in evaluating the impact of acne on psychosocial health.

Case-control Surveys

The majority of studies on the psychosocial impact of acne have been case reports and case-control surveys. Although case-control design studies are rapid to perform and relatively inexpensive, disadvantages include potential bias, inability to predict events of precedence, and to provide estimates on prevalence, incidence, or relative risk. The majority of these surveys are based on small samples with responses compared to historical controls or responses from other disease categories (see Table 1).

Study n Instuments Controls Pre-treatment Post-treatment
Kellet, et al.(1999)1 34 Hospital Anxiety Depression Scale Normal population, general dermatology outpatients, psoriasis, oncology, and psychiatric patients • Depression and anxiety scores greater than for general dermatology patients, psoriasis, and oncology patients
• Females had more emotional distress
• 18% clinically significant depression
• 44% clinically significant anxiety		 Improvement in obsessive-compulsiveness, shame, embarrassment perfectionism, self-consciousness, locus of control, body image
Gupta,
et al. (1998)2		 72 Carroll Rating Scale for Depression Inpatients and outpatients with alopecia areata, atopic dermatitis, psoriasis Depression scores higher than alopecia areata, atopic dermatitis, psoriasis outpatients
6% expressed active suicidal ideation compared to none in alopecia areata and 2% each in atopic dermatitis and psoriasis outpatients
Mallon,
et al. (1999)3		 111 Dermatology Life Quality Index, Rosenberg measure of self-esteem, General Health Questionnaire 28, Short-Form 36 Population sample 18-64 yrs. • 41% possible cases of non-psychotic psychiatric disorder
• impairment in mental health, social functioning, energy, role limitations
• mental health scores worse than for asthma, epilepsy, diabetes, back pain, arthritis, coronary artery disease
• No correlation with acne grade
Klassen,
et al. (2000)4		 130 Dermatology Life Quality Index, EuroQoL, Short-Form 36 Population sample 20-39 yrs. Pain/discomfort, anxiety/depression, lower perceived health status Improvement in all parameters
Lasek,
et al. (1998)5		 60 Skindex Patients with psoriasis, benign skin lesions, healthy volunteers Most bothersome feature of acne: appearance
Functioning, emotions, and symptoms
Greater effects on QoL with more severe acne grade and age		 Improvement in all parameters / older patients more likely to report no improvement in their acne
Krowchuk, et al. (1991)6 39 Piers-Harris self-concept scale Normative Embarrassment and social inhibition embarrassment, social inhibition, greater acceptability of facial appearance to peers
Myhill,
et al. (1988)7		 94 Specific questionnaires Adult normal controls, adolescent high school students No difference compared to controls Improved social assertiveness, social appraisal, confidence
Grahame, et al. (2002)8 34 Hospital Anxiety Depression Scale, Rosenberg self-esteem, Positive/ negative affectivity Self control self-esteem, positive affect
anxiety, depression, negative affect
Van der Meeren,
et al. (1985)9		 40 Amsterdam biographic questionnaire, social anxiety scale Normal adult and student population neuroticism, psychosomaticism, anxiety

Table 1: Case-control surveys: psychosocial effects of acne vulgaris

Psychological abnormalities include self-reported depression and anxiety, embarrassment, social inhibition, and psychosomatic symptoms including pain and discomfort. Of particular note is that clinically important depression and anxiety were reported in 18% and 44% of acne patients, respectively.1 Furthermore, 6% of acne patients in one study reported active suicidal ideation.2

Patients with acne had greater impairment in mental health scores compared with those with asthma, epilepsy, diabetes, back pain, arthritis, or coronary artery disease.3 Furthermore, acne patients reported higher depression and anxiety scores when compared to psoriasis patients and those attending oncology or general dermatology clinics.1,2

Longitudinal evaluation of psychometric outcomes has demonstrated that effective treatment of acne was accompanied by improvement in self-esteem, affect, obsessive-compulsiveness, shame, embarrassment, body image, social assertiveness, and self-confidence. The majority of these patients were treated with oral isotretinoin (71%).1,4-7

Unemployment in acne patients was evaluated in 625 patients aged 18-30 years in Leeds, England. Controls were randomly selected patients from general practitioner records and matched for age and gender. This study revealed that unemployment levels were significantly higher among acne patients of both genders compared to controls (16% vs. 9% in males; 14% vs. 9% in females; p<0.001). However, social status, academic background, and intelligence were not included in the analysis.10

Cross-sectional Population Surveys

Cross-sectional studies are more rapid and less expensive to conduct than cohort studies. They are useful for controlling subject selection and controlling measurements, and can yield prevalence data. A particular limitation is the difficulty of establishing causal relationships or sequencing of events. There are a limited number of these studies in the literature evaluating the association of acne and psychological disturbances in the context of the general population (see Table 2).

Study Sample Psychometric Instrument Controls Findings
Aktan, et al. (2000)11 2657 students HAD Unaffected cohort No difference in depression or anxiety scores
Smithard, et al. (2001)12 317 students SDQ Unaffected cohort Higher levels emotional and behavioural difficulties

Table 2: Cross-sectional surveys: psychosocial effects of acne vulgaris

A recent survey of 2,657 students from Turkey, aged 14-20 years, detected a prevalence of acne, anxiety and depression of 23%, 25%, and 13% respectively. In addition, the Hospital Anxiety and Depression scale (HAD), was administered to 308 acne patients whose responses were compared to responses of the same number of gender-matched controls. No differences were detected in the subscale scores for anxiety or depression in acne versus control subjects. Limitations of this scale include uncertain sensitivity and responsiveness in detecting psychological abnormalities in a relatively young outpatient population, and specificity in determining attributability of anxiety and depression to acne.11

In a survey of 317 students aged 14-16 from England, an age-appropriate, validated scale, i.e., the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ), was used to assess psychological health. Subjects with acne were twice as likely to score in the borderline or abnormal range of the SDQ compared to unaffected students. Furthermore, the presence of acne was associated with higher levels of emotional and behavioral difficulties.12

Cohort Studies

While a prospective longitudinal cohort study is the most powerful trial design for evaluating incidence and investigating potential causes of psychosocial dysfunction in acne patients, such a survey has not been performed. A cohort of school children followed from pre-adolescence to early adulthood would be of particular value in determining the sequence of events in the complex interaction of acne and psychological changes of adolescence, and in providing estimates of incidence and relative risks of these outcomes. Such a survey may be a relatively inexpensive extension or addition to longitudinal studies on general health in the pediatric population.

Summary

Acne vulgaris is associated with excess psychosocial morbidity, which can be reduced by effective treatment. Furthermore, acne is associated with a greater psychological burden than a variety of other disparate chronic disorders. The causal inference provided by current literature between acne and psychosocial disability requires validation by a longitudinal cohort evaluation.

References

  1. Kellett SC, Gawkrodger DJ. The psychological and emotional impact of acne and the effect of treatment with isotretinoin. Br J Dermatol 140(2):273-82 (1999 Feb).
  2. Gupta MA, Gupta AK. Depression and suicidal ideation in dermatology patients with acne, alopecia areata, atopic dermatitis and psoriasis. Br J Dermatol 139(5):846-50 (1998 Nov).
  3. Mallon E, Newton JN, Klassen A, Stewart-Brown SL, Ryan TJ, Finlay AY. The quality of life in acne: a comparison with general medical conditions using generic questionnaires. Br J Dermatol 140(4):672-6 (1999 Apr).
  4. Klassen AF, Newton JN, Mallon E. Measuring quality of life in people referred for specialist care of acne: comparing generic and disease-specific measures. J Am Acad Dermatol 43(2 Pt 1):229-33 (2000 Aug).
  5. Lasek RJ, Chren MM. Acne vulgaris and the quality of life of adult dermatology patients. Arch Dermatol 134(4):454-8 (1998 Apr).
  6. Krowchuk DP, Stancin T, Keskinen R, Walker R, Bass J, Anglin TM. The psychosocial effects of acne on adolescents. Pediatr Dermatol 8(4):332-8 (1991 Dec).
  7. Myhill JE, Leichtman SR, Burnett JW. Self-esteem and social assertiveness in patients receiving isotretinoin treatment for cystic acne. Cutis 41:171-3 (1988).
  8. Grahame V, Dick DC, Morton CM, Watkins O, Power KG. The psychological correlates of treatment efficacy in acne. Dermatol Psychosom 3(3):119-25 (2002 Sep).
  9. Van der Meeren HLM, van der Schaar WW, van den Hurk CMAM. The psychological impact of severe acne. Cutis 36(1):84-6 (1985 Jul).
  10. Cunliffe WJ. Acne and unemployment. Br J Dermatol 115(3):386 (1986 Sep).
  11. Aktan S, Ozmen E, Sanli B. Anxiety, depression, and nature of acne vulgaris in adolescents. Int J Dermatol 39(5):354-7 (2000 May).
  12. Smithard A, Glazebrook C, Williams HC. Acne prevalence, knowledge about acne and psychological morbidity in mid-adolescence: a community-based study. Br J Dermatol 145(2):274-9 (2001 Aug).
STL Volume 9 Number 7

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM THIS ISSUE